Shoppable Livestreaming ecommerce retail tech podcast | RetailTechPodcast

Shoppable Livestreaming Market Analysis

By Darius Vasefi Oct 20 2020

Livestream shopping (aka shoppable livestreaming, live-video commerce, live commerce, liveshopping and more) is a new way to shop by purchasing products, or services inside a real time livestreaming video session where both sides, the seller and shopper, are present at that moment and communicating with each other interactively either via full audio or in-app messaging.

Although the concept is referred to in different terms such as live shopping, live video shopping, livestream shopping and more the common differentiating experience is the interactive live stream video merged into a shopping experience including shopping cart, payment, shipping and other e-commerce features.

The key benefit of a fully shoppable livestream is that “your customers never have to leave the app” to make purchases and the personal engagement results in higher AOV (Average Order Value) and Conversion.

 

LIVESTREAM SHOPPING IS DIFFERENT FROM VIDEO SHOPPING (see report 2 here)

An important point is that “shoppable live streaming” is different from “shoppable video”.  Shoppable video is typically the ability to buy specific items in a pre-recorded video and there are several players in the space.

 

On the other side of the industry the more expansive modes of Live experiences are creeping into virtually every aspect of consumer experiences and business with what has been called “Nexgen Live” which goes beyond the transactional commerce side and into gaming, entertainment, travel, music, the metaverse (AR/VR) and more.

 

HISTORY OF SHOPPABLE LIVESTREAMING

Shoppable livestreams are gaining traction due in large part to the explosive growth of live video.  Virtually all the major social apps are offering some form of live video, and as consumers are utilizing this feature more, the app companies are increasing investment and innovation into the space.

There is also the element of the “super app” which is already underway in china with Taobao and is an eventual, possible, outcome in the future as only a handful of very large apps will be where most of the people on the planet will be spending their time on.  Shopping and commerce is a massive industry and it’s only natural for both consumers and brands / retailers to want to do business in the same experience.

Although startups were working on the live shopping concept since the 90’s real consumer traction and transaction volume began starting in the mid 2010’s in China by the Daiguo cross-border shopping concept where shopping agents in the US used apps like WeChat to shop for their clients in China.

The practice only gained ground by increased demand from high end fashion forward Chinese consumers and the additional posers of live streaming and morphed into what we today call Shoppable livestreaming.  The sheer amount of sales in China has really taken off in China and the growth has only intensified since the Pandemic, practically pulling 2023 projections 3 years forward and projections for 2020 are at $123 Billion in China with compelling reasons why livestream shopping is catching on with consumers.

Livestream shopping in China has been compared to the next evolution of QVC and many US players are following the same experience as we discuss below.  ‘Kim Kardashian sold 150,000 bottles of her KKW perfume in just a few minutes when it was featured on top live streamer Viya’s show last year on Tmall, the main rival to Taobao Live. An incredible 13 million viewers watched the event.

In the US there were concepts around live shopping as early as the first dot com boom with startups including LiveShops, but the effort did not take off due to multiple factors including infrastructure, lack of interest from customers and mostly a lack of a genuine "need" from the US consumers since they had ample and easy access to any product they wanted within reach of a few minutes drive to the mall.  The US market is turning now and there are multiple companies, including the largest ecommerce and technology players, joining the livestream commerce space and the COVID-19 Pandemic has accelerated the growth and usage of livestream shopping by consumers.

Coresight Research predicts live-stream shopping events in the U.S. will generate $25 billion in sales by 2023. The streamed events are already a big business in China. A Tommy Hilfiger live-stream show in China in August attracted 14 million viewers and sold out of 1,300 hoodies in two minutes.

 

Brands are also experimenting with livestream commerce including Levis, HilfigerCadillac and Pomelo among many others.

 

SHOPPABLE LIVESTREAM USER EXPERIENCE MODELS

Overall there seem to be three different experience models used in the shoppable livestream space:

1. The Instagram/Snapchat mobile app model with one-many shopping and on-screen faves, messages and reactions.

2. The QVC style web (mainly) experience with full page with, almost TV like CX one-many sessions and combines messaging and some voice.

3. The private one-one app experience for VIP style livestream shopping experiences.

 

CURATION

A large differentiator in how the companies present products to shoppers is the differentiation between curated products or open commerce.  Starting with QVC and HSN and extending to the majority of other companies doing the same model curation is a common factor where the company selects and produces the sales session based on what they want to sell.  In contrast the more open models allow individual sellers such as brands, influencers, retailers and even individual shopping agents select their own products and use a marketplace approach to help consumers discover and shop for what they are looking for (or happen to find).

 

THE PLAYERS

In this report we’ll look at the current players in the space (alphabetical list) with a heavier focus on the US and the opportunities for investors and brands to get a head start on a coming tsunami of a new way of shopping, a hybrid of catalog based ecommerce, in-store shopping and real time livestream video.

Note: this is not an exhaustive list of all the companies.  Members of our Premium research receive the comprehensive report and additional analysis and insights plus other benefits.

1. Amazon Live

Starting in 2016 with the launch of Style Code Live Amazon has been experimenting with the Live Shopping experience and in 2019 launched Amazon Live which is in full motion for the new Prime Day sales dates 10/13,14.

Amazon Live is similar to the QVC and HSN experiences and seems to be a direct offensive move to take a bite out of the leader in the live shopping sector Quarate Retail Group born from the merger of QVC and HSN.

Amazon Live also has a specific app for creators to produce and stream their shows.

Amazon Live

2. China (overview)

Although livestreaming in general is a fast growing industry, in China live-streaming comes with unique risks, chief among them unprecedented competition: YY and Momo are among the largest of the hundreds of streaming services that at one point sprang up across the country, taking advantage of low barriers to entry.

“There’s a movement in China now called xiaofei shengji, which means consumer upgrade, before, people only cared about price. Now they care about design, uniqueness and authenticity.”

A young designer brand from Connecticut called Welden recently made a striking debut in China via livestream, generating nearly $300,000 of sales in just two days. Zoe Zhang and Mark Yuan, co-founders of And Luxe Inc., a US-based retailer focused on introducing high-end fashion and accessory brands to Chinese consumers, has put together the livestream for Welden. They have partnered with Taobao global since April 2017, and frequently leverage the platform to help over 80 brands like Welden enter the Chinese market.

Brands can monetize in China (and anywhere) without having a physical store.

The most popular category of products for And Luxe livestreams have been beauty and cosmetic items.

Today, there are hundreds of streaming platforms in China, including both pure livestream players like Yizhibo, Meipai, Huajiao Live, Kuaishou, and Inke, as well as Alibaba’s e-commerce sites Tmall and Taobao. 

China-based blogger incubator Ruhan enables live streamers to monetize on their fan base by offering help with the manufacture of goods, social media marketing, and building Taobao stores. Zhang Dayi is the poster child for this business model, with her store reportedly pulling in $46 million in 2016, slightly surpassing Kim Kardashian’s earnings ($45.5 million).

There are also brand consulting companies such as AndLux specializing on helping US brands sell to the Chinese consumers using shoppable livestreaming on Taobao.

China livestreaming apps retail tech podcast

3. The Call List

The Call List plugin powers video calls from influencers to all their followers at once. Shopify-powered brands can share products to be shopped in realtime. 

4. CommentSold

Based in Huntsville, AL CommentSold is a comment selling and e-commerce platform that powers 11K online retailers, primarily in women's fast fashion. CommentSold is known for "comment selling," where retailers post on Facebook and Instagram and shoppers comment "sold" to purchase items.  

CommentSold has expanded into the live shopping experience with it’s Live Selling feature.

5. Dote (defunct)

Led by CEO Lauren Farleigh Dote started in 2014 with the concept of the Shopping Party, partnered with high profile celebrities, Raised $12M in April 2019 to launch live shopping and ran into some operational issues and is not active any more.

6. Facebook

According to Facebook, Live Shopping is the best way to sell items, interact directly with viewers and gain potential customers, all in real time. When you sell products through Live Shopping on Facebook, you are live streaming as you feature your products.

“When you sell products through Live Shopping on Facebook, you are live streaming as you feature your products. This allows you to share more information, demonstrate your products, answer questions from viewers and respond to their reactions. It’s highly interactive for you and your viewers, and when viewers want to make a purchase, they can do it right in the live stream.”

In 2020 Facebook Introduced Facebook Shops as a new option in the main Facebook app to bring more attention to the shopping options available.

As part of its burgeoning eCommerce push, in 2019 Facebook acquired video commerce startup Packagd, which, prior to the acquisition, had been focused on enabling users to make direct purchases of products via live-stream, unboxing-type videos. 

According to Bloomberg: "The social media company bought Packagd, a five-person company founded by Eric Feng, a former partner with Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers, and most of the startup’s team joined Facebook in September. Packagd was building a shopping product for YouTube videos. “Think of it as a re-imagination of QVC or a home shopping network,” Feng said in a 2017 interview with Bloomberg Television’s Emily Chang.

In April 2020 Facebook announced updates to its rollout of shopping features across both Facebook and Instagram including the major launch of  Facebook Shop, which is the counterpart to Instagram Shop. Meant to be a page for discovering new brands and products, and eventually shopping them in-app, Facebook Shop pulls in suggested products for a user from individual Facebook Shops.

7. Instagram

With over 1 Billion active users globally (over 150 Million in US and Canada)  and the most engaging social app Instagram is and should be on top of every consumer brand and retailer. 83% of Instagram users are discovering new products on the platform, The 18–24 year old age group is the largest of the demographics and a mostly even split between the genders with 51% female and 49% male. And 90% of accounts follow at least 1 business

Shopping on Instagram is in full swing and the company is offering many options, including Live Shopping. The Shopping and checkout features are relatively new to Instagram. But the significant benefit now, for shoppers and brands, is that without leaving the app, users can now search for products, add to a shopping bag and checkout.


Instagram live shopping has had positive results in the beauty products sector and appears destined to be a key part of the shopping experience on IG in the future

In 2018 Instagram launched IGTV which is both an independent app and also available from within the main Instagram app. Brands and retailers have many options on using IGTV shopping to add a new channel to their mix.

Instagram live shopping retail tech podcast

8. LiSA  (Germany)

LiSA is a software shoppable livestreaming start-up “born in Germany” founded by Philippe and Sophie Frères and incubated at the Founders factory in London.

 

9. NTWRK

Launched in 2018 and based in Los Angeles, NTWRK is a shopping app focused on the “culture fashion” and streetwear industry including sneakers, streetwear, collectibles, and more during each episode also billing itself as QVC for Gen Z.  

A classic example of the influencer marketing phenomenon Ntwrk’s e-commerce app offers limited-edition gear coveted by cool kids sold via scheduled, limited-time drops—often with a celebrity attached.

Started by past creators of Complex Network’s festival ComplexCon, Ntwrk has raised at least $10M in funding from brands and influential entertainers in the world including Warner Bros. Digital Networks, Drake, Live Nation, Foot Locker and Main Street Advisors, whose investors include Jimmy Iovine and LeBron James.

Although NTWRK bills itself as the home shopping network for Gen Z as of October 2020 the website does not display any live shows, and the app also is mostly focused on drops and catalog shopping. 

Recently Ntwrk partnered with TikTok and artist Joshua Vides to offer a shoppable livestreaming experience to TikTok users and move into the transactional commerce space.

 

NTWRK live shopping retail tech podcast

10. Popshop Live

Based in New York Popshop Live is a mobile live streaming marketplace where talented individuals can create and host their own shopping channel.

Popshop Live is a reimagining of the Home Shopping Network, or QVC, for the year 2020. Individual sellers, or established brands and stores, can get on the platform to create and host their own shows. The product also integrates with Shopify to help sellers manage their inventory and POS during the show without any additional hassle.

Japan LA, one of the biggest stores on the platform, did more sales on Popshop Live than its offline and online sales combined on an average Saturday before the pandemic. Popshop Live told TechCrunch that Japan LA did $17,000 in sales with more than 1,500 individual checkouts in a single show. (AOV = $11.30)

11. Qurate Retail Group

As the parent company of QVC and HSN and arguably the oldest live video-based shopping option, Qurate is the current US leader in terms of volume for companies with live shopping as the main source of revenue, with over $14 billion in revenues in 2018.

12. Shopshops

Started in 2016 and based in New York Shopshops is a mobile app with a  livestream, interactive cross-border shopping marketplace that connects retail stores globally with Chinese consumers looking to purchase US premium apparel. 

Think of it as QVC for the social media generation. Rather than watch idly, ShopShops’ viewers can type in requests asking their hosts to try on jewelry or swivel the camera toward another section of a store.

In addition to an app, ShopShops maintains online stores on Alibaba’s Taobao, China’s premier online shopping site, and on WeChat.

13. Talkshoplive

Based in Los Angeles and founded in 2018 Talkshoplive is another QVC-style livestream shopping company. 

TalkShop is an online live streaming platform for multi-category products. Its product offerings include beauty care products, apparel, fashion accessories, food & beverages, and more. The company provides a platform where users can browse through live videos showing the products being used. Users can ask questions regarding the products they want to purchase while the live streaming takes place
From dressmaker Julie Mollo (best known as the creator of pop star Katy Perry's iconic fruit-inspired ensembles) to America's favorite Tupperware queen in Alabama to a succulent wall designer in Los Angeles to digital stars Megan Nicole (with a clothing and accessories line) and Chloe Lukasiak (with her book), talkshoplive's inaugural brands and sellers are sure to pique interest and offer unique products.

14. TikTok

TikTok is the latest entrant into the video social commerce scene and amassing a massive following overseas and also in the US.  In fact TikTok is the most popular Chinese app in the US, so that the US government has gone after it to divest from it’s chinese parent and become an independent US company which can fall under the oversight of US laws for data privacy and storage.


TikTok live is the live version of the app and it’s first test into shoppable livestreaming was introduced as a partnership with NTWRK.

15. Visional

Founded in 2016 in Southern California and spinning out of the Startup Studio InfiniVentures Labs, Visional is a livestream shopping platform and app providing a different experience to shoppers and brands and retailers.

Visional’s shopping experience is different from the QVC-style shopping in that it is  focused on private, 1:1, livestream audio and video interactive sales, a fully functional e-commerce (shopping cart, product catalogs, shipping, tax, tipping, transaction processing and more) plus a CRM and analytics. 

Brands, retailers and individuals can use Visional to provide the livestream shopping experience to their own audiences, and shoppers can discover live shopping events from the app near them or in other areas.

Visoinal’s shopping app is currently available in the Apple iOS App Store for both iphone and iPad.

WHO IS MISSING

The biggest names missing in an active experimentation of shoppable livestreaming in late 2020 are Youtube/Google and Snap, plus pretty much all retailers large such as Walmart and Macys, smaller chains and independents.  

Photo-messaging app Snapchat has added shopping features, such as augmented reality (AR) lenses that point to an online checkout page but no evidence of a shoppable livestream option any time soon.

Google is planning to turn YouTube into a major shopping destination  For Google the goal is to convert YouTube’s bounty of videos into a vast catalog of items that viewers can peruse, click on and buy directly, according to people familiar with the situation. 

The company is also testing a new integration with Shopify Inc. for selling items through YouTube, but no news about a livestream shopping feature yet.
Walmart has been looking into the social commerce and video commerce space for a while specifically looking at how Douyin in China has been performing and most recently in a bid to purchase the US assets of TikTok which has not gone thru so far.

WHAT'S NEXT

As we can see the mix of solutions and options for shoppable livestreaming is already becoming overwhelming and difficult to manage and differentiate.  Brands and retailers have to make fundamental, often long-term decisions now to start using this new way of selling and will need help on the strategic, technology, implementation and success of livestream shopping.  Planning and experimentation must stop now to learn how to navigate the commerce waters in the new decade.

The decisions to be made now will impact business in the next 2-4 years because it takes time to implement, experiment, get good at and build awareness and audience.

 

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive the latest interviews and research reports.

By signing up you agree to our Privacy Policy & Terms of Use. You can unsubscribe anytime